# What to Say When the Review Is Fake

> What counts as fake under Google’s policy and what does not, the order to work in, how to word the reply, and what to do about competitors and ex-staff.

Source: https://reviewresponsetool.co/responding-to-fake-reviews/  
Site: ReviewResponseTool  
Updated: 13 November 2026

---

Short answerReport it, then reply calmly without calling the reviewer a liar. Google's policy prohibits content that is not based on a real experience, reviews posted from multiple accounts at one person's request, content posted on a competitor's profile to undermine them, and reviews based on a conflict of interest such as current or former employment. Reporting is the route; it is slow and often unsuccessful, which is why the public reply matters more than the report.

Responding to fake reviews starts with an uncomfortable fact: every business believes some of its bad reviews are fake. A few of them are right, and the ones that are right still have to handle it in public while the report sits in a queue.

## What actually counts as fake

The [prohibited and restricted content policy](https://support.google.com/contributionpolicy/answer/7400114) is specific. Fake engagement includes content not based on a real experience, reviews paid for directly or in kind, and content posted from multiple accounts at the request of one person. It also prohibits posting content on a competitor's profile to undermine their reputation.

Rating manipulation covers incentivised reviews and content based on a conflict of interest, which the policy describes as including current or former employment, a contractual relationship, or other professional or personal affiliations such as industry competitors or family.

Fake engagement, incentives and conflicts of interest.

## What does not count

- A review that is unfair, exaggerated or one-sided.

- A review from somebody who did not buy, if they genuinely interacted with the business.

- A complaint about something outside your control.

- A review you believe is from a competitor but cannot evidence.

- An old review about a problem you have since fixed.

Most reviews businesses call fake fall into this list. Treating them as fake produces the worst possible reply, which is a public accusation that turns out to be wrong.

## What to do, in order

-
### Check your records properly
Name, date, service. Check spellings and partners' names. A surprising share of "we never served this person" turns out to be a booking under a different name.

-
### Report it
Through the [report inappropriate reviews](https://support.google.com/business/answer/4596773) process, stating which policy it breaks rather than that it is unfair.

-
### Screenshot everything
With the date. Reviews can be edited, and your evidence may be needed later.

-
### Reply in public
Calmly, without the word fake.

-
### Wait
Then let it go. Repeated reports rarely change the outcome.

Check, report, screenshot, reply, then let it go.

## How to word the reply

The aim is to signal to a reader that something is off, without accusing anybody. "We have no record of a booking under this name, and the details described do not match any job we have carried out. If we have got that wrong, please contact us directly and we will put it right."

That sentence does the work. It is factual, it leaves room for being mistaken, and the next customer reads it as a business that checked rather than as a business that is cross.

## Extortion attempts

Occasionally a review is accompanied by a demand: pay, or refund, or the review stays. Do not pay, and do not offer anything in exchange for removal, which the policy prohibits in both directions. Keep every message, report the review, and if money is being demanded, treat it as a matter for the police rather than for marketing.

## When it is a competitor

It happens, and it is explicitly against the policy. The response is still the same: report, screenshot, reply once, move on. Public accusations against a named competitor create a legal risk for you and make your profile the place where an argument is happening.

If you have a genuine pattern, several reviews with similar wording arriving together, collect the evidence properly and report the pattern rather than the individual reviews.

## Reviews from former staff

The conflict of interest rule covers current or former employment directly. A review from an ex-employee about working conditions is not a customer review, and it is reportable on that basis. Say nothing about the person in public: reply once, neutrally, and keep any employment matter where it belongs.

## Reviews about the wrong business

The most straightforward removable review is one left on your profile by mistake, usually because two businesses share a name or a building. These are factual errors rather than bad faith, they are reportable, and they are among the few that do get removed reliably. Reply briefly saying it appears to be meant for another business, which also helps anyone reading it.

## A worked case

A letting agent received four one star reviews in two days, all from accounts with no other activity, all mentioning a specific member of staff by name, all with similar phrasing.

They reported each one, citing fake engagement and the pattern of unusual volume, and kept dated screenshots. They replied to each with the same two lines: no record of any dealings under those names, and an invitation to make contact directly.

Two were removed after several weeks, two stayed. The reply was what mattered for the months in between, and the profile continued to collect genuine reviews throughout, which did more to dilute the four than any report could.

## Why reports fail

Businesses conclude the system is broken when a report comes back rejected. Usually the report simply did not state a policy breach. "This review is unfair" is not a ground for removal; "this review is from a former employee, which is a conflict of interest under the content policy" is.

Two other common reasons. The evidence is in your head rather than in the report, so there is nothing to assess. Or the review is genuinely borderline, in which case leaving it up is the default and no amount of resubmission changes that.

## Keeping perspective

One suspicious review among forty genuine ones does almost nothing to a rating or to a reader. The damage comes from the response: a long angry reply, a flurry of staff reviews, or a profile where the owner argues with three different people. Handling it quietly costs you less than the review itself ever would.

## What not to do

Do not ask staff, friends or family to post positive reviews in response. That is a conflict of interest under the same policy and swaps one problem for a worse one. Do not offer the reviewer anything to remove it, which is explicitly prohibited. And do not stop asking genuine customers, which is the only reliable remedy available to you.

### Spot patterns before they build
Monitor every review across your locations, with alerts on low ratings and sudden clusters.

[Negative review monitor](/tools/negative-review-monitor/) [Removal analyser](/tools/google-review-removal-analyzer/)

## Frequently asked questions

**Q: What counts as a fake review?**
Content not based on a real experience, paid reviews, content posted from multiple accounts at one person’s request, competitor attacks, and conflicts of interest such as employment.

**Q: Is an unfair review a fake review?**
No. Unfair, exaggerated and one-sided reviews are allowed. Treating them as fake leads to a public accusation that is often wrong.

**Q: How should I word a reply to a suspected fake?**
Factually and without the word fake: no record under that name, the details do not match any job, and an invitation to contact you if that is wrong.

**Q: What about a review from a former employee?**
The conflict of interest rule covers current and former employment directly, so it is reportable. Say nothing about the person in public.

**Q: Can I ask staff to post positive reviews to balance it out?**
No. That is a conflict of interest under the same policy, and it swaps one problem for a worse one.

## Sources
The Google documentation behind the guidance on this page. Google changes these pages without notice, so check the date on any figure before you rely on it.

- [Prohibited and restricted content](https://support.google.com/contributionpolicy/answer/7400114)
- [Report inappropriate reviews on your Business Profile](https://support.google.com/business/answer/4596773)
- [Tips to get more reviews and reply well](https://support.google.com/business/answer/3474122)
